High Court decision
High Court brings greater clarity on trust distributions
The High Court has rejected the ATO’s long-standing view that an unpaid trust distribution automatically constitutes a Division 7A loan.
Read the full update
The High Court has handed down an important decision that will impact many private business groups using discretionary trusts and corporate beneficiaries.
10 June 2026 – In Commissioner of Taxation v Bendel [2026] HCA 18, the High Court rejected the ATO’s long-standing view that an unpaid trust distribution automatically constitutes a Division 7A loan.
The rules in Division 7A target situations where private companies provide benefits to shareholders or their associates through payments, loans or forgiven debts. When triggered, the rules apply as if the company had paid an unfranked dividend to the recipient of the benefit.
Why this matters
The upshot: an unpaid distribution will not necessarily amount to a Division 7A loan simply because the corporate beneficiary hasn’t demanded payment. Many private groups distribute income to a corporate beneficiary so it is taxed at the corporate rate (25% or 30%) while cash stays in the trust to fund working capital and growth.
What happens with existing loan arrangements?
The ATO has released a Decision Impact Statement (26 June 2026), confirming it will generally administer the law in line with the Court’s decision – but with important caveats.
- Existing agreements stay in force. Formal written loan agreements put in place under the ATO’s previous view can’t simply be unwound because of the Bendel decision.
- Minimum repayments still apply. Trusts must keep making minimum loan repayments each year until the loan period ends or the loan is repaid in full.
- Other integrity rules still bite. Later loans to a shareholder or their associate can still trigger a deemed dividend.
- Section 100A remains in play. Where another party enjoys the real benefit of a distribution, adverse tax outcomes can still apply.
Looking ahead: proposed trust tax reforms
The Federal Budget announced a 30% minimum tax rate for discretionary trusts from 1 July 2028, and income distributed to corporate beneficiaries will generally face double taxation. A Treasury consultation paper also suggests Division 7A could be extended to unpaid distributions.